Let’s see how the hell DameDesuYo all of a sudden gets the blue seal of approval.
Table of Contents
Release format: MKV (502 MB, 10-bit)
Translation: Crunchy Edit
Wap Level: Partially edited wap
English style: American English.
Speed: Quick (<48 hours)
Group website: http://damedesuyo.com/
IRC channel: #[email protected]
Like with every crunchyedit, this will be graded on a pass/fail basis. If they manage not to add mistakes to the script, they pass. If they do add any mistakes, even one, they fail.
Ed only. It was done well, except I want them to try a little bit harder with this translation.
Yes, technically “hang around” is what tsurumu means, but in this context (they’re purposely far apart from each other) I would have chosen something else like “pal around.”
I would have preferred “if you encounter our target” since the only enemy they have to worry about is the superpowered magician named Saori.
Forgot honorifics in these lines.
Final Grade: Pass
Jesus, was that so hard? I think this simucast edit is the first one I’ve ever passed. It seems that DameDesuYo has discovered the secret to being a top-tier group: take Crunchyroll scripts, don’t try to fix too much what’s not broken, clean up the timing, and add good typesetting and karaoke. However, there will be some who won’t be impressed by the fact that all they really did to the original crunchy script was add honorifics and change “witch” to “magician,” but that’s a a discussion for another day.
24 thoughts on “Translation Review (Pass/Fail): [DameDesuYo] Gokukoku no Brynhildr – 03”
You know, it’s funny. If a group does a really thorough edit of a CR script, they’ll get a review from D_S, but they’ll probably end up failing your TL review. If they do a really minimalistic edit, which this is, D_S will disqualify them, but they will pass your review.
What would you give a release that had been really thoroughly edited while maintaining the integrity of the translation? Feels like a group deserves special praise if they can succeed in editing a CR script well without destroying the translation.
I give those edits a Pass with High Distinction.
B-But it’s disqualified…
Because what’s the point of reviewing what’s basically a Crunchyroll script? Maybe somewhere down the line all we have to do is review original crunchyscripts and be done with it.
I guess you can’t really go wrong with any group for this show
WOW ARE YOU FOR REAL? there is a serious DDY love thing going on lately. seriously. you guys must be collaborating with them to make them seem super sugoi or something.
just. fucking. wow.
never coming here again. so fucking biased.
A fucking pass with heaps of praise for their original work. Such a bias. GTFO.
Not sure if trolling or not.
Look at the link in his name, maybe that’ll give you a clue.
I honestly still can’t tell.
Don’t let the door hit ya where the good Lord split ya.
No, you are fucking idiot. Please die in a fire already.
This post and its replies are a good example of Poe’s Law in action.
No it’s not, you idiot.
Better than the fail whale, I always say.
Thank You Kokujin-kun for giving us helpful reviews and not wasting time on porn.
Can we expect a review of Asenshi’s/Commie’s version of Mekaku City Actors any time soon?
I’ll probably do Captain Earth next.
Please do a porn review next, kokujin-kun.
A hentai TL review would be good.
Yeah, some of those subbers have been getting away with murder for years.