Fansub Review: [Monokage] Kamisama no Memochou (Episode 04)

A-Tier, Fansub Review — By on August 8, 2011 8:42 pm

This post was written by Dark_Sage. He is Dark_Sage.

Twitter YouTube   


I’ve been giving out A- grades like candy recently! Delicious, delicious candy!

File size: 339 MB

Release format: MKV

Japanesiness: Honorifics. Japanese name order.

Karaoke.

Typesetting.

Font. This font is like a rollercoaster. Not a good rollercoaster, either. It’s like a rollercoaster that molests young children while smoking unfiltered cigarettes. The worst kind of rollercoaster. :(

Either my video card is dying or this is bad encoding. Not quite sure which at the moment.

Making curtains? Hmm? Pretty sure Master-sama doesn’t make curtains as a side job. Drop the “making” from the sentence.

injecting protein into what?

“Drop this simpleminded notion that injecting me with protein will make me grow!”

Also, obligatory “I’d love to inject her with my protein.”

strengthen, you mean.

You can’t wear a sunglass, but you can wear sunglasses. Well… I guess you technically could wear a sunglass, but it’d be more like monocleglass. Hm, a little bit of MS Paint and…

Okay, I’ll accept it.

 

Watchability: Quite watchable.

Overall grade: A-

So I guess this brings them head-to-head with Chihiro for this show.

  • Monokage’s typesetting and karaoke are better.
  • The English errors were less phrasing errors like in Chihiro’s and more word choice issues, which is less distracting.
  • Chihiro’s font is better, but honestly, both groups didn’t do a great job on that end (you can hardly tell the difference between uppercase and lowercase in Chihiro’s and Monokage’s is like a rollercoaster as previously mentioned).

Assuming that fucked-up encode right there isn’t their fault, I’d have to recommend Monokage. Actually, I’d probably recommend Monokage anyway because one encoding derp doesn’t affect the entirety of the series (but it would drop the grade here).

However, their torrents have no seeders and they have no other way to acquire their files — either through DDL or IRC. So, while theoretically I’m recommending Monokage, they fucked up their distro so bad that I’m going to recommend Chihiro as the most practical choice.

Grade:
Show:
Tags: , , ,

14 Comments

8thSin says:

I pretty much stopped taking these guys seriously after seeing this TL note on their website:

15:24 How about my balls?

{Spoiler from the light novels} Tetsu’s offer to bet his testicles makes sense because the yakuza, Nemo, is gay.

Maybe they were just trolling.

Dark_Sage says:

That is them undoubtedly trolling. Or maybe they’re just retarded (would explain their distro situation). However, I didn’t see anything approaching a troll in this release or I’d have made sure to bitch about it.

Raph95 says:

I like the font, though. It’s easy-to-read to me, plus it’s not a typical one.

I guess it’s tastes, though.

Dark_Sage says:

Note the k’s and the f’s. They’re very, very awkward. But if it’s fine for you, don’t mind me.

Johnyboi says:

I agree with both of you. The font in general is quite nice, but the k’s and f’s (and G’s) are pretty ugly.

I’ve taken it upon myself to edit the font to improve the k’s, f’s and G’s. http://www.sendspace.com/file/jm1e02

Here’s a screenshot with the offending characters in question:
http://i53.tinypic.com/2hejblc.png

I’ll probably send it to Monokage for use too, if they accept.

Nyara♥ says:

This. At least the selection of size/color/border it’s ok.

KZ says:

Did you have a bad roller coaster ride in your childhood D_S? XD

Narru says:

Just wondering about the top-right pic of the typesetting part as those 3 words “準備中” means “In Preparation” instead of “Closed”. Had to say I read from a Chinese’s point of view and did a google translate to reconfirm it.

Please ignore my post if anyone think it’s not that important.

8thSin says:

It does say “In Preparation”

The problem is, I’ve never seen an “In Preparation” sign in English. Technically, that’s “Closed”. We (UTW) went for “Opening Soon” instead.

Narru says:

I do understand the motive for using “Closed” or “Opening Soon” and I’m not trying to say it’s wrong, was just wondering will others think “In Preparation” sounds better or not.

If I do offend any translator or fansub group here, I apologize for my previous post then.

8thSin says:

I was just clearing things up.

If it’s wrong, then it’s wrong. Nothing to be offended about :)

Narcisse says:

hmm, something is disturbing me.
I’m not an english native speaker, but what’s better?
Wear a sunglass or put a sunglass?
kthx

diskkjockey says:

Wear sunglasses or put on sunglasses. Sunglasses are referred to as a pair of sunglasses and therefore (outside of D_S’ example) you cannot have a “sunglass.”

diskkjockey says:

Of course, the article “the” is also helpful. Wear the sunglasses or put on the sunglasses for example.

Leave a Comment